Natural Farm Real Fish Dog Treats - Dried Anchovies, 1 Ingredient - Anchovies, Collagen, Omega 3, Vitamin B&D for a Shiny Coat

Absolutely stinks, but dog loves them! I will say, just expect partial pieces at the bottom of the bag (as you would a bag of chips), it isn't a deal breaker for me since realistically nobody can make a bag where every fish is intact 100%. Plus, I use the partial fishes as training treats anyway so it's helpful for that! Or a nice topper for kibble.

It's more of a bag of crushed up anchovies, not whole anchovies, so you can't really offer a treat, it's more like sprinking a topper over food. Perhaps that's just the one bag I purchased, but I don't know if I will try again, might go to a different brand, which is unfortunate, because I purchase other items from this brand that are great.

I have a fairly picky and mostly toothless elderly Chihuahua that is very careful about picking items that require too much biting force. She was able to chew/gnaw on this and enjoyed it as a treat. Wish they were cheaper though. The smell is strong but it just smells like a fish (that it is), I did not have any problems with the package containing that smell though. I really like the packaging because it has the velcro like closure. Would buy again!

DO NOT FEED THESE TO YOUR PET!! THEY'RE DANGEROUS! They're VERY BONEY and just got stuck in my dogs esophagus! Everyone is complaining about it being in pieces which is completely accurate and coated with something weird but I was pleased with the small pieces until it got lodged in her throat! She's finally stopped freaking out, drooling, and hiccuping but I'll go ahead and warn others.

Thumbs up!

Nothing big to report, I haven’t tasted them. I don’t plan to. The dogs seem to like them but don’t find them the best treat they’ve ever had. One thing I can comment on is that they are not the best value for the quality/value. They make for kind of small treats for large dogs. We use them for treats in their food so they work well for that. Three stars

This were more dust & scraps in the bag that I received than whole pieces. She liked other fish treats here much more.

Changed the way my dogs eat forever now my fur babies are on a half raw and half kibble and they don't give me any issues eating anymore. I use to have a hard time getting my shih tzus to eat. I'd buy all kinds of goodies to mix in the food to try to get them to eat and it was very expensive. I can say now that I found out about this kind of things they let me know it's time for their lovely food. Happy fur babies now and way better health. No more biting feet no eyes watering is a huge change.